Family of Liars by E. Lockhart received mixed reviews. Critics praised the book for its gripping narrative and emotional depth, especially its exploration of family dynamics and secrets. However, some felt it lacked the originality of its predecessor, We Were Liars, and found the plot twists predictable. Overall, it’s a compelling but somewhat flawed follow-up.

Readers who relish suspenseful, character-driven narratives set in picturesque, isolated locales will adore E. Lockhart's Family of Liars. Fans of We Were Liars and Gillian Flynn's Sharp Objects will find the enthralling tales of secrets, betrayal, and family dynamics captivating. The book's nuanced emotional depth and vivid storytelling make it a compelling read.

In E. Lockhart’s young adult novel Family of Liars, protagonist Carrie Sinclair recounts her 17th summer on her family’s private Beechwood Island during the late 1980s, dealing with addiction, grief over her sister Rosemary's death, and complex family dynamics. Carrie navigates a tumultuous relationship with a visitor named Pfeff, discovers a dark family secret, and confronts past traumas while seeking her place within the Sinclair family.

Mysterious / Dark / Melancholic / Bittersweet / Unnerving

- Family of Liars serves as a prequel to the widely acclaimed novel We Were Liars, providing fans with a deeper dive into the history of the Sinclair family.
- E. Lockhart incorporates her signature style of suspenseful and twist-laden storytelling in Family of Liars, which has been praised for its intricate plot and emotive writing.
- The story is set on a private island, a recurring setting that the author uses to explore themes of privilege, family dynamics, and deception.

**Caroline “Carrie” Sinclair**  
Carrie is a socially conscious and intelligent seventeen-year-old dealing with family grief, personal insecurities, and addiction. She struggles with her family's problematic history and the death of her youngest sister, Rosemary.

**Lawrence “Pfeff” Pfefferman**  
Pfeff is a visitor to Beechwood Island and serves as Carrie’s love interest. He is defined by a mix of charm and a darker complexity, influencing Carrie's growth throughout the text.

**Penny Sinclair**  
Penny is Carrie's younger sister, admired by Carrie for her beauty but also a source of jealousy. Throughout the narrative, she grapples with concealing her true self from her family.

**Tipper Sinclair**  
Tipper is Carrie’s mother, embodying the role of a dedicated homemaker who manages her life's challenges by keeping busy. She offers insights into varying personal expressions of grief and the pressure to meet societal expectations.

E. Lockhart

Novel

We Were Liars

Fiction

Guide

Study Guide

Before You Read

Explore Family of Liars reviews, reading age recommendations, and essential genre and thematic details before you start reading.

Before You Read Family of Liars | SuperSummary

title

content

Overview

Get ready to explore Family of Liars and its meaning. Our full analysis and study guide provides an even deeper dive with character analysis and quotes explained to help you discover the complexity and beauty of this book.

Family of Liars Summary and Study Guide

Background

Family of Liars Background

chapter

chapterType

section

Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1: “A Story for Johnny” - Part 3: “The Black Pearls”

Parts 1-3

Family of Liars Parts 1-3 Summary & Analysis

Part 4 “The Boys”

Part 4 Family of Liars Part 4 Summary & Analysis

Part 5: “Mr. Fox” - Part 6: “A Long Boat Ride”

Parts 5-6

Family of Liars Parts 5-6 Summary & Analysis

Part 7: “The Bonfire”- Part 8: “After”

Parts 7-8

Family of Liars Parts 7-8 Summary & Analysis

character

Character Analysis

Family of Liars Character Analysis

theme

Themes

Family of Liars Themes

Symbols & Motifs

Family of Liars Symbols & Motifs

quote

citation

Important Quotes

Family of Liars Important Quotes

primaryCharacter

Essay Topics

Family of Liars Essay Topics

Family of Liars

Before You Read

Super Short Summary

Reviews & Readership

Review Roundup

Who Should Read Family of Liars?

Reading Age

Book Details