When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McLain has received mixed reviews. Critics praise its captivating mystery and in-depth character development, but some find the pacing slow and the multiple timelines confusing. The novel's exploration of trauma and healing resonates strongly, but the blending of real events with fiction might not appeal to all readers.

Readers who enjoy gripping psychological thrillers and character-driven narratives like Paula Hawkins' The Girl on the Train or Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl will be captivated by Paula McLain's When the Stars Go Dark. With its blend of mystery, emotional depth, and intricate storytelling, it’s perfect for those seeking a compelling and evocative read.

In When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McLain, San Francisco detective Anna Hart returns to her childhood home in Mendocino to grapple with the accidental death of her daughter but gets entangled in the investigation of multiple missing girls, prompting her to confront past traumas and uncovering a potential serial killer linked to her own high school friend's unresolved murder. The novel includes themes of sexual abuse, trauma, and murder.

Mysterious / Melancholic / Dark / Suspenseful / Emotional

- When the Stars Go Dark combines fictional elements with true stories of missing persons to create a deeply immersive experience, reflecting Paula McLain's interest in real-life mysteries.
- The novel's protagonist, Anna Hart, shares some similarities with McLain's own experiences, as the author has a personal connection to the Northern California setting which plays a crucial role in the book.
- Paula McLain, widely known for The Paris Wife, explores new territory in When the Stars Go Dark, marking her first foray into the psychological thriller genre.

**Detective Anna Hart**  
A dedicated and compassionate detective known for her intuitive approach to solving cases involving missing and abused children. She is deeply driven by her emotional connection to the children she seeks to protect.

**Sheriff Will Flood**  
A diligent and methodical sheriff haunted by his obsession with solving the murder of a childhood friend, desperately seeking closure for unsolved cases involving teenage girls.

**Caleb Ford**  
An enigmatic and troubled character whose deep psychological and emotional bonds lead to dark and unsettling paths. He is intricately tied to the central mystery of missing and abducted girls.

**Cameron Curtis**  
A resilient and multifaceted young girl whose mysterious disappearance serves as the catalyst for the narrative. Her experiences reflect the complexities of identity and trauma in youth.

Paula McLain

Adult

Novel

Fiction

Guide

Study Guide

Before You Read

Explore When the Stars Go Dark reviews, reading age recommendations, and essential genre and thematic details before you start reading.

Before You Read When the Stars Go Dark | SuperSummary

title

content

Overview

Get ready to explore When the Stars Go Dark and its meaning. Our full analysis and study guide provides an even deeper dive with character analysis and quotes explained to help you discover the complexity and beauty of this book.

When the Stars Go Dark Summary and Study Guide

Background

When the Stars Go Dark Background

chapter

chapterType

section

Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1: “Signs and Vapors”-Part 2: “Secret Things”

Prologue-Part 2, Chapter 14 

When the Stars Go Dark Prologue-Part 2, Chapter 14  Summary & Analysis

Part 2, Chapters 15-29

When the Stars Go Dark Part 2, Chapters 15-29 Summary & Analysis

Part 2: “Secret Things”-Part 3: “Time and the Maiden”

Part 2, Chapter 30-Part 3, Chapter 44

When the Stars Go Dark Part 2, Chapter 30-Part 3, Chapter 44 Summary & Analysis

Part 3: “Time and the Maiden”-Part 4: “The Bent Grove”

Part 3, Chapter 45-Part 4, Chapter 60

When the Stars Go Dark Part 3, Chapter 45-Part 4, Chapter 60 Summary & Analysis

Part 4, Chapters 61-70

When the Stars Go Dark Part 4, Chapters 61-70 Summary & Analysis

character

Character Analysis

When the Stars Go Dark Character Analysis

theme

Themes

When the Stars Go Dark Themes

Symbols & Motifs

When the Stars Go Dark Symbols & Motifs

quote

citation

Important Quotes

When the Stars Go Dark Important Quotes

primaryCharacter

Essay Topics

When the Stars Go Dark Essay Topics

When the Stars Go Dark

Before You Read

Super Short Summary

Reviews & Readership

Review Roundup

Who Should Read When the Stars Go Dark?

Reading Age

Book Details